In Paulsen–Schreieder [PS19] and vDdB–Paulsen [DBP20], the authors/we show that any block of numbers
satisfying , , and (characteristic only) can be realised as the modulo reduction of a Hodge diamond of a smooth projective variety.
While preparing for a talk on [DBP20], I came up with the following easy example of a Hodge diamond that cannot be realised integrally, while not obviously violating any of the conditions (symmetry, nonnegativity, hard Lefschetz, …).
Lemma. There is no smooth projective variety (in any characteristic) whose Hodge diamond is
Proof. If , we have , with equality for all if and only if the Hodge–de Rham spectral sequence degenerates and is torsion-free for all . Because contains an ample class, we must have equality on , hence everywhere because of how spectral sequences and universal coefficients work.
Thus, in any characteristic, we conclude that , so and the same for . Thus, is a fibration, so a fibre and a relatively ample divisor are linearly independent in the Néron–Severi group, contradicting the assumption .
Remark. In characteristic zero, the Hodge diamonds
cannot occur for any , by essentially the same argument. Indeed, the only thing left to prove is that the image cannot be a surface. If it were, then would have a global 2-form; see e.g. [Beau96, Lemma V.18].
This argument does not work in positive characteristic due to the possibility of an inseparable Albanese map. It seems to follow from Bombieri–Mumford’s classification of surfaces in positive characteristic that the above Hodge diamond does not occur in positive characteristic either, but the analysis is a little intricate.
Remark. On the other hand, the nearly identical Hodge diamond
is realised by , where is a curve of genus . This is some evidence that the full inverse Hodge problem is very difficult, and I do not expect a full classification of which Hodge diamonds are possible (even for surfaces this might be out of reach).
[Beau96] A. Beauville, Complex algebraic surfaces. London Mathematical Society Student Texts 34 (1996).
[DBP20] R. van Dobben de Bruyn and M. Paulsen, The construction problem for Hodge numbers modulo an integer in positive characteristic. Forum Math. Sigma (to appear).
[PS19] M. Paulsen and S. Schreieder, The construction problem for Hodge numbers modulo an integer. Algebra Number Theory 13.10, p. 2427–2434 (2019).